Chernihiv
Aachen
Mińsk Mazowiecki
Milan
4 countries, one network

How the score is built

This page lists every input behind the cluster scores on Ukraine’s road to the EU: each step, each rating, its date, its official source and what our code found when it checked. No cluster has a score yet. 0 of 36 areas have a counted rating.

What this page is for

A reader or a journalist can check every number in a cluster score here. For each cluster this page shows the five process steps and the Commission’s rating of each policy area, with the date, the official source, the sentence we quote, the page of the report, and whether our code found the sentence in the official document.

The same list is a table that you can download: method.csv, 66 rows, one for each step and each area. An empty cell means that the value is not available.

Columns of the download
What each column says
ColumnWhat it says
clusterNumber of the cluster, 1 to 6.
cluster_nameName of the cluster.
kindWhat the row is: a process step, or one area with its rating (an area without a rating has one row that says so).Words: step, rating
inputThe step or the area. A step is one of screened, ready, opened, benchmarks, closing. An area is a chapter (ch5 is chapter 5) or another area.
input_labelThe same, in words.
dimensionRating rows. Preparation counts in the score; progress is used for the momentum word only.Words: prep, progress
subRating rows. The part of an area that is rated in more than one part, if any.
reportRating rows. The report the rating comes from.
dateOn a step row, the day of the step. On a rating row, the day of the Commission’s statement.
report_publishedRating rows. The day the report was published.
ratingRating rows. The Commission’s rating as the key of its scale.
pointsThe points the step has earned, or the rating is worth. Empty when not available.
max_pointsThe most a step, or a rating on its scale, can earn.
stateThe state of the step or the rating.Words: Steps: reached, implied, not-recorded, in-progress. Ratings: counted = Counted; momentum-only = Used for momentum only; awaiting-check = Awaiting check; awaiting-approval = Awaiting approval; too-old = Too old to count; rejected = Rejected; other-report = Not used: another report is used; incomplete-area = Not counted yet: another rating of this area is not counted; not-on-cluster-list = Not counted: the area is not on the cluster list; not-rated = No rating entered yet.
quoteRating rows. The sentence we quote.
pageRating rows. The page of the report.
source_urlThe official source: the first source of a step, or the document of a rating.
check_stateWhat our code found when it checked the source of a step or the sentence of a rating.Words: ok = our code matched the source or found the sentence; recheck-due = found, and a new check is due; old = not confirmed recently; failed = the check failed; none = not checked yet
checked_onThe day of that check.
approvalRating rows. The approval as written in the ratings file.Words: approved, proposed, rejected
approved_byRating rows. Who approved or rejected it, as written in the file.
pull_requestRating rows. The pull request in which it was approved or rejected.
approved_onRating rows. The day of the approval or rejection.
rejected_forRating rows. Why a rejected rating was rejected.Words: wrong-label = the label did not fit the sentence; wrong-area = the sentence belongs to another area; not-a-rating = the sentence is not a rating; other = another reason

To check one rating:

  1. Open the source link in its row.
  2. Go to the page named in the row.
  3. Find the quoted sentence.
  4. Compare the Commission’s words with the rating and the points.

The formula in words

The score. Score = 30 % of the process points + 70 % of the preparation points, rounded to a whole number. Each part runs from 0 to 100. This is method version 1.0. A change to these numbers after ratings have been seen needs a new version, and the score log marks it.

Process points. A cluster earns points for five steps. Together they are worth 100. The last step is shared between the chapters of the cluster: each closed chapter earns its share. A step that must have happened before a later step on record is called implied and earns its points; the tables say so. Interim benchmarks set at an opening are not counted.

Points of the five steps
StepPoints
All chapters screened15
Ready to open15
Opened25
Closing benchmarks set10
Chapters closed35

Preparation points. Once a year the Commission rates the policy areas of each chapter. We turn the rating into points as in the table. When the Commission words a rating as between two steps, we use the point halfway between them (12.5, 37.5, 62.5 and 87.5). The spacing is our choice.

Points of each rating
The Commission’s wordingPoints
Early stage0
Between early stage and some level of preparation12.5
Some level of preparation25
Between some level of preparation and moderately prepared37.5
Moderately prepared50
Between moderately prepared and a good level of preparation62.5
Good level of preparation75
Between a good level of preparation and well advanced87.5
Well advanced100

A cluster’s preparation points are 75 % of the average of its counted areas plus 25 % of its lowest counted area. The lowest area has extra weight because a cluster closes only when all its chapters close.

When something is missing. A score is shown only when at least three quarters of a cluster’s areas have a counted rating. The table “At a glance” below gives the number needed for each cluster. A missing rating is never replaced by an average or by zero.

Age. A report counts for 14 months after it was published; after 13 months the page says that a newer report is due. A rating counts only if our code found its sentence in the official document in the last 90 days; after 45 days a new check is due. All counted ratings of a cluster come from one report.

Momentum. The Commission’s progress ratings are used only for the momentum word, never in the score. Their points: backsliding 0, none 25, limited 37.5, some 50, good 75, very good 100.

Range. The weights and the spacing are choices. We recalculate each score with 9 other reasonable settings and show the lowest and highest result as its range. The settings:

  • average of the areas only, with no extra weight on the weakest
  • more weight on the process part
  • less weight on the process part
  • more of the process points kept for closing chapters
  • closing benchmarks counted as earned in a cluster that is open
  • ratings between two steps rounded down to the step below
  • ratings between two steps rounded up to the step above
  • areas without a counted rating set to the lowest rated value
  • areas without a counted rating set to the highest rated value

The same text, shorter, is under “How the score works” on the road page.

Before any score is shown

Three things must be done first. Each one is open until it is done and closed on the day it is done. While one is open, no cluster has a score, and the code enforces that. 3 of 3 are still open.

  1. Chapter lists compared

    Each cluster’s list of chapters is compared with the Council’s own list.

    Open: not done yet

  2. Scale fixed

    The way the Commission’s rating words are turned into points is fixed after it has been read in a real report.

    Open: not done yet

  3. Weights fixed

    The weights of the score are approved.

    Open: not done yet

How a rating gets in

A rating enters the ratings file only through a pull request. That is a proposed change that is published on GitHub before it takes effect. A person approves it. After that, our code looks for the rating’s sentence in the official document. A rating is counted only after both: a person’s approval and our code finding the sentence. It leaves the count again when its sentence has not been found in the last 90 days or when its report is too old.

The approval is recorded in the file: who approved it, in which pull request and on which day. The tables show that record as it is written. It is only as strong as the rule of our code repository that every change to the ratings file needs an approved pull request. This page shows the record and cannot prove the rule.

Awaiting approval
The rating is proposed. No person has approved it yet. It is not counted.
Awaiting check
A person approved it, but our code has not found its sentence in the official document recently. It is not counted.
Counted
Approved, the sentence was found recently, and its report is not too old.
Too old to count
Its report is older than the limit above.
Rejected
A person rejected the proposed rating. It is listed under “Rejected entries”.
No rating entered yet
No rating of this area is in the file.

Inputs by cluster

As of ; scores calculated for .

On a narrow screen each table scrolls sideways: swipe it to see every column.

No Commission report has been entered into this score yet.

At a glance
ClusterProcess pointsAreas with a counted ratingNeeded for a scoreScore
1. Fundamentals55 of 1000 of 86No score yet
2. Internal market55 of 1000 of 97No score yet
3. Competitiveness and inclusive growth55 of 1000 of 86No score yet
4. Green agenda and sustainable connectivity30 of 1000 of 43No score yet
5. Resources, agriculture and cohesion30 of 1000 of 54No score yet
6. External relations55 of 1000 of 22No score yet

Cluster 1. Fundamentals

No score yet. 0 of 8 areas have a counted rating; 6 are needed.

Process steps of cluster 1
StepDateOfficial sourceOur code’s checkPoints
All chapters screened News: Ukraine successfully completes its screening process (opens in a new tab)Show on the timeline Source checked 16 Nov 2026 15 of 15
Ready to open Press release: European Council text on Ukraine, 26 June 2025 (opens in a new tab)Show on the timeline Check failed on 16 Nov 2026 15 of 15
Opened Press release: EU and Ukraine open first accession negotiations cluster (opens in a new tab)Show on the timeline Check failed on 16 Nov 2026 25 of 25
Closing benchmarks set Not recorded yet. 0 of 10
Chapters closed 0 of 5 chapters closed. 0 of 35
Process points55 of 100

“All chapters screened” is the day the screening of every chapter, in all six clusters, was finished, so the steps are not always in date order: a cluster can be ready before that day.

No rating has been entered for any of the 8 areas of this cluster: Chapter 5. Public procurement; Chapter 18. Statistics; Chapter 23. Judiciary and fundamental rights; Chapter 24. Justice, freedom and security; Chapter 32. Financial control; Functioning of democratic institutions; Public administration reform; Economic criteria.

Cluster 2. Internal market

No score yet. 0 of 9 areas have a counted rating; 7 are needed.

Process steps of cluster 2
StepDateOfficial sourceOur code’s checkPoints
All chapters screened News: Ukraine successfully completes its screening process (opens in a new tab)Show on the timeline Source checked 16 Nov 2026 15 of 15
Ready to open Press release: European Council text on Ukraine, 23 October 2025 (opens in a new tab)Show on the timeline Check failed on 16 Nov 2026 15 of 15
Opened Press release: negotiations on internal market, competitiveness and inclusive growth (opens in a new tab)Show on the timeline Check failed on 16 Nov 2026 25 of 25
Closing benchmarks set Not recorded yet. 0 of 10
Chapters closed 0 of 9 chapters closed. 0 of 35
Process points55 of 100

No rating has been entered for any of the 9 areas of this cluster: Chapter 1. Free movement of goods; Chapter 2. Freedom of movement for workers; Chapter 3. Right of establishment and freedom to provide services; Chapter 4. Free movement of capital; Chapter 6. Company law; Chapter 7. Intellectual property law; Chapter 8. Competition policy; Chapter 9. Financial services; Chapter 28. Consumer and health protection.

Cluster 3. Competitiveness and inclusive growth

No score yet. 0 of 8 areas have a counted rating; 6 are needed.

Process steps of cluster 3
StepDateOfficial sourceOur code’s checkPoints
All chapters screened News: Ukraine successfully completes its screening process (opens in a new tab)Show on the timeline Source checked 16 Nov 2026 15 of 15
Ready to open Joint statement: Commissioner Marta Kos and Deputy Prime Minister Taras Kachka (opens in a new tab)Show on the timeline Source checked 16 Nov 2026 15 of 15
Opened Press release: negotiations on internal market, competitiveness and inclusive growth (opens in a new tab)Show on the timeline Check failed on 16 Nov 2026 25 of 25
Closing benchmarks set Not recorded yet. 0 of 10
Chapters closed 0 of 8 chapters closed. 0 of 35
Process points55 of 100

No rating has been entered for any of the 8 areas of this cluster: Chapter 10. Digital transformation and media; Chapter 16. Taxation; Chapter 17. Economic and monetary policy; Chapter 19. Social policy and employment; Chapter 20. Enterprise and industrial policy; Chapter 25. Science and research; Chapter 26. Education and culture; Chapter 29. Customs union.

Cluster 4. Green agenda and sustainable connectivity

No score yet. 0 of 4 areas have a counted rating; 3 are needed.

Process steps of cluster 4
StepDateOfficial sourceOur code’s checkPoints
All chapters screened News: Ukraine successfully completes its screening process (opens in a new tab)Show on the timeline Source checked 16 Nov 2026 15 of 15
Ready to open Joint statement: Commissioner Marta Kos and Deputy Prime Minister Taras Kachka (opens in a new tab)Show on the timeline Source checked 16 Nov 2026 15 of 15
Opened Not recorded yet. 0 of 25
Closing benchmarks set Not recorded yet. 0 of 10
Chapters closed 0 of 4 chapters closed. 0 of 35
Process points30 of 100

No rating has been entered for any of the 4 areas of this cluster: Chapter 14. Transport policy; Chapter 15. Energy; Chapter 21. Trans-European networks; Chapter 27. Environment and climate change.

Cluster 5. Resources, agriculture and cohesion

No score yet. 0 of 5 areas have a counted rating; 4 are needed.

Process steps of cluster 5
StepDateOfficial sourceOur code’s checkPoints
All chapters screened News: Ukraine successfully completes its screening process (opens in a new tab)Show on the timeline Source checked 16 Nov 2026 15 of 15
Ready to open Joint statement: Commissioner Marta Kos and Deputy Prime Minister Taras Kachka (opens in a new tab)Show on the timeline Source checked 16 Nov 2026 15 of 15
Opened Not recorded yet. 0 of 25
Closing benchmarks set Not recorded yet. 0 of 10
Chapters closed 0 of 5 chapters closed. 0 of 35
Process points30 of 100

No rating has been entered for any of the 5 areas of this cluster: Chapter 11. Agriculture and rural development; Chapter 12. Food safety, veterinary and phytosanitary policy; Chapter 13. Fisheries and aquaculture; Chapter 22. Regional policy and coordination of structural instruments; Chapter 33. Financial and budgetary provisions.

Cluster 6. External relations

No score yet. 0 of 2 areas have a counted rating; 2 are needed.

Process steps of cluster 6
StepDateOfficial sourceOur code’s checkPoints
All chapters screened News: Ukraine successfully completes its screening process (opens in a new tab)Show on the timeline Source checked 16 Nov 2026 15 of 15
Ready to open Press release: European Council text on Ukraine, 23 October 2025 (opens in a new tab)Show on the timeline Check failed on 16 Nov 2026 15 of 15
Opened Press release: EU opens accession negotiations with Ukraine on external relations (opens in a new tab)Show on the timeline Check failed on 16 Nov 2026 25 of 25
Closing benchmarks set Not recorded yet. 0 of 10
Chapters closed 0 of 2 chapters closed. 0 of 35
Process points55 of 100

No rating has been entered for any of the 2 areas of this cluster: Chapter 30. External relations; Chapter 31. Foreign, security and defence policy.

Commission reports in the file

No Commission report has been entered into this score yet.

Data health

Every input has its own date, and the date says what it is: the day it was checked, retrieved, calculated or published. The age is counted from that date and moves with your day. The newest saved result of the daily check is from .

The state of each input
InputDateThe date is the day it wasAgeStateDetail
Source checks of the stepschecked3 daysCurrent17 of 43 steps have a source checked in the last 14 days.
Official news feedschecked3 daysPartly available2 of 5 feeds answered.
Statisticsretrieved3 daysCurrent6 figures, each with its own date.
Commission reportsnot availablepublishednot availableNothing yetNo Commission report has been entered into this score yet.
Checks of the rating sentencesnot availablecheckednot availableNothing yetNo approved rating yet, so nothing to check.
Score calculationcalculated for3 daysCurrentCalculated from the inputs that are on this page.
Watch for new Commission reportsnot availablecheckednot availableNot availableNo detector result has been saved yet.
Score lognot availablelast entrynot availableNothing yetNo entry yet: no score has changed.

Rejected entries

No rating has been entered yet, so nothing has been rejected.

Score log

Each time the score shown for a cluster changes, one line is added. Old lines are never rewritten. A change of method is marked as such, so it is never read as a jump. Newest first.

The log is empty: no score has been shown yet, so none has changed.

Download the inputs (CSV)

Found a mistake?

Write to contact@elysium.ngo and tell us which step, number or rating it is.